ABSTRACT
AIM To investigate the clinical therapeutic effects of modified Shenqi Decoction in treating earlyto-middle stage nontraumatic osteonecrosis of femoral head (NONFH) due to kindey deficiency and blood stasis syndrome,and its impacts on serum TNF-α,CRP,NO,SOD as well.METHODS Totally,104 cases of eligible patients were randomly divided into traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) group,chemical medicine group and TCM combined with chemical medicine group,38 cases in each group,for a three-month course of treatment.The TCM group was dosed with modified Shenqi Decoction,the chemical medicine group with sodium alendronate,and the TCM combined with chemical medicine group with both modified Shenqi Decoction and sodium alendronate.The Harris SF-36,SF-36,FPS-R and TCM symptoms assessment were applied to estimating the efficacy of three groups before and after the treatment.So were the check of the serum TNF-α,CRP,NO,SOD levels,and rates of efficiency after treatments and six-month follow-ups,and incidence of adverse reactions during the treatment among all the three groups.RESULTS The efficiency rates were found to be in the following sequence:the chemical medicine group (76.5％) ＜ the TCM group (83.8％) ＜ the TCM combined with chemical medicine group (97.2％) (P ＜ 0.05).The TCM combined with chemical medicine group had its post-treatment scores of Harris SF-36,FPS-R,FPS-R,TCM symptom and the serum TNF-α,CRP,NO,SOD levels significantly improved as compared with other two groups (P ＜ 0.05).And the revealed incidence of adverse reactions was ranked as the TCM group (2.7％) ＜ the TCM combined with chemical group (30.6％) ＜ the chemical medicine group (70.6％) (P ＜ 0.05).CONCLUSION Modified Shenqi Decoction is superior to sodium alendronate in the treatment of NONFH due to kidney deficiency and blood stasis syndrome for its better performance in both the efficacy and the incidence of adverse reactions,and its synergistic effect with use of sodium alendronate may associate with its capability in offsetting the adverse reactions of sodium alendronate.
ABSTRACT
To explore the clinical effect of Sanbitang recipe in treatment for the rheumatoid arthritis (RA) with kidney empty and cold-dampness symptom and its safety. A total 168 cases eligible patients were randomly divided into the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) group, the chemical medicine group and the TCM combined with chemical medicine group, with 56 cases in each group. The TCM group was treated with Sanbitang recipe; The chemical medicine group was given methotrexate tablets; And Sanbitang recipe and methotrexate tablets was adopted in the TCM combined with chemical medicine group. A course of treatment was 16 weeks. Health assessment questionnaire (HAQ), disease activity scores 28-joint counts (DAS28), visual analogue scale (VAS), TCM symptom, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), C-reactive protein (CRP), cyclic citrullinated peptides (CCP) and rheumatoid factor (RF) were detected. The efficiencies and incidence of adverse reactions in the three groups were compared. The total effective rate of the TCM combined with chemical medicine group was 92.7%, which was higher than 79.2% of the TCM group and 82.4% of the chemical medicine group (P<0.05). There was no statistically significant difference between the TCM group and the chemical medicine group. This suggested that Sanbitang recipe was effective in treating rheumatoid arthritis (RA) with kidney empty and cold-dampness symptom. After treatment, the scores of HAQ, DAS28, VAS, ESR, CRP, CCP and RF of the TCM combined with chemical medicine group were significantly higher (P<0.05) among the three groups. There was no statistically significant difference between the TCM group and the chemical medicine group. This indicated that Sanbitang recipe could effectively alleviate the clinical symptoms of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) with kidney empty and cold-dampness symptom. In terms of efficiency and incidence of adverse reactions, the order from low to high was that the TCM group (3.8%, 2/53)<the TCM combined with chemical medicine group (16.4%, 9/55)<the chemical medicine group (33.9%, 18/53) (P<0.05). Sanbitang recipe is effective in treating RA with kidney empty and cold-dampness symptom, with no obvious difference from methotrexate tablets and a low incidence of adverse reactions. Sanbitang recipe shows a remarkable effect in treating RA with kidney empty and cold-dampness symptom.